Open Letter on Quassim Cassam’s Statements concerning Gaza

Published 23 November 2026. Last updated 23 November 2026.

We are writing this open letter to distance ourselves from recent statements concerning Gaza issued by our colleague Quassim Cassam, particularly in the form of two academic articles (‘Peace in Gaza?’, in: Analyse & Kritik 48(1) 2026, pp. 157-77, henceforth Cassam 2026a; ‘Beyond the Pale: McMahan on Peace in Gaza’, in: Analyse & Kritik forthcoming 2026, pp. 1-23, henceforth Cassam 2026b). As postgraduate students, researchers, and teaching assistants in the Department of Philosophy at the University of Warwick – working at the same institution as Cassam – we believe it is our responsibility to state unequivocally and publicly that we strongly condemn his claims. Many of us were, in fact, so shocked by these statements that we felt compelled to take collective action, expressing our conviction that they contradict the values we hold as philosophers, as well as universal principles of human dignity that ought to be upheld by all.

In particular, we reject Cassam’s claims:

  • that the only viable path to peace is for Israel to continue its military offensive until Hamas is “crushed” (Cassam 2026a: 173), in the sense of being rendered “militarily and politically impotent” (Cassam 2026b: 21);
  • that this goal is to be pursued despite the immense loss of Palestinian life, with at least 73,000 Palestinians reportedly killed in Gaza since 7 October 2023 (the figure also cited by Cassam 2026b: 14), the majority of them civilians, including more than 21,000 children1, and with the actual death toll estimated to be considerably higher, and despite nearly two million Palestinians being in need of shelter, two thirds of them relying on food aid to survive2;
  • that the war’s “bad effects”, including mass civilian deaths, are “not excessive” but proportionate “[i]f the war’s good effects include the crushing of Hamas” (Cassam 2026b: 21);
  • that there is “no basis to the charge that Israel has committed genocide in Gaza” (Cassam 2026b: 1); and that it is “simply impossible to draw well-founded conclusions about the significance” of the reported 73,000 Palestinian deaths without first establishing how many of the dead were combatants, were “murdered by Hamas”, or died as “human shields” – even while conceding that Israel “might be guilty of war crimes or crimes against humanity” (Cassam 2026b: 14).

These statements are morally deeply problematic and rest on flawed assumptions and forms of argumentation, particularly for the following reasons:

  1. Cassam’s articles portray mass civilian deaths as an acceptable cost of achieving goals supposedly beneficial to Israel and Palestinians (Cassam 2026b: 21). We strongly reject the suggestion that, after the atrocities of Hamas on 7 October, such immense suffering and loss of human life can be justified, whether in the name of Israel’s security or the “liberat[ion]” of Palestinians from Hamas (Cassam 2026b: 21). We also question the framework on which this conclusion rests: to weigh the deaths of tens of thousands of civilians against a war’s strategic “good effects” (Cassam 2026b: 21) risks treating those lives as quantities to be traded – and, as the evidence set out in point 4 below shows, the language of proportionality has itself been used to justify mass civilian death3.
  2. Whether Israel and/or Hamas meet the conditions for reaching a formal peace agreement (Cassam 2026a) does not determine whether Israel’s military offensive should continue. We reject the suggestion that the absence of such an agreement justifies the continuation of a military offensive that has caused immense suffering and the deaths of tens of thousands of Palestinians, most of them civilians. We believe the Israeli government bears a particular responsibility to bring it to an end, given its vastly superior military capacities.
  3. Cassam barely addresses the well-documented evidence supporting allegations of war crimes, crimes against humanity, and genocide. Instead, he simply questions the credibility of the UN Human Rights Council and Amnesty International, citing their alleged “antipathy to Israel” (Cassam 2026b: 13). In support, he refers to opinion pieces in The Times4 and The Atlantic5, including one criticising Amnesty’s position on J. K. Rowling and gender, without establishing how this undermines the credibility of its evidence on Gaza. He also entirely dismisses the 2025 resolution on Gaza issued by the International Association of Genocide Scholars6 on the basis of the association’s membership structure, arguing that it lacks “any special authority to pronounce on whether Israel has committed genocide in Gaza” (Cassam 2026b: 13), rather than engaging with the extensive evidence it presents. Regarding the reported death toll of at least 73,000 Palestinians, Cassam asks how many were combatants, were killed by Hamas, “used … as human shields”, or died in attacks on buildings used for military purposes, and what “military value” the targets had, concluding that without answers to these questions, “it is simply impossible to draw well-founded conclusions about the significance of the 73,000 figure” (Cassam 2026b: 14). Yet in his earlier article, Cassam reports estimates that between 50 and 80 per cent of those killed were civilians, noting that “most scholarly estimates are at the higher end of this range” (Cassam 2026a: 173–74, fn. 14). We find it deeply troubling that the immense scale of Palestinian loss of life and injury is called into question in this way, without corresponding engagement with the available evidence or the moral gravity of civilian deaths. These failures to engage with evidence are especially disconcerting insofar as they contribute to defending and promoting the continuation of Israel’s military offensive and perpetuate a narrative that obscures the gravity of the crimes against Palestinians.
  4. The available evidence that Cassam fails to engage with to any serious degree extends far beyond the figures indicated above. For instance, the recent NAZA documentary7 (Abraham & Szor 2026) reports on Israeli military strategies of mass killings and the military’s routine willingness to accept, on the basis of AI analysis and automated surveillance, civilian death tolls in the tens or hundreds in order to kill a single alleged Hamas combatant. Further evidence includes the ICC’s arrest warrants for Netanyahu and former Defence Minister Yoav Gallant, issued in November 2024 on the basis of reasonable grounds to believe that they bore criminal responsibility for war crimes and crimes against humanity, including the war crime of starvation as a method of warfare.8 The UN Independent International Commission of Inquiry concluded in September 2025 that Israel had committed genocide in Gaza and that senior Israeli officials, including Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, had incited genocide.9 This list could easily be extended.

We reject and strongly condemn Cassam’s statements in our capacity as postgraduate students and teaching assistants in the Department of Philosophy at the University of Warwick. We regard these issues not only as matters of academic disagreement, but as matters of fundamental moral responsibility that demand our public response.

Signatories

The signatories are writing in a personal capacity and not on behalf of the University of Warwick or the Department of Philosophy.

  • Haris Ali Akhtar
  • William Bain
  • Berke Can
  • Emma Clinton
  • Si Courtenage
  • Miranda Crabtree
  • İsmail Deniz Demirkan
  • Patrick Denton
  • Nansi Dingle
  • Chris Hall
  • Joseph Horspool
  • Leo Jenkins
  • Sebastian Leyton Blanco
  • Bradley Lister
  • Anpeng Liu
  • David López Baeza
  • Ciaran McElligott
  • Ates Metin
  • Fridolin Neumann
  • Ade O'Brien
  • Tiago Rodrigues
  • Diego Romero Laje-Dávila

Notes

  1. European Commission, Palestine: humanitarian aid factsheet. ↩
  2. BBC News, ‘World Food Programme forced to cut aid to Gaza due to funding shortages’. ↩
  3. Eyal Weizman, ‘Necro-Economics: Death by Algorithm’, London Review of Books 48(20). ↩
  4. The Times, ‘Amnesty has been captured by a pernicious form of progressivism’. ↩
  5. The Atlantic, opinion piece on anti-Israel bias in NGOs, March 2025. ↩
  6. International Association of Genocide Scholars, resolution on Gaza, August 2025 (PDF). ↩
  7. IMDb entry for the documentary (Abraham & Szor 2026). ↩
  8. International Criminal Court, arrest warrants issued for Benjamin Netanyahu and Yoav Gallant, November 2024. ↩
  9. United Nations, ‘Israel has committed genocide in the Gaza Strip, UN Commission of Inquiry finds’, 16 September 2025. ↩

Changes to this page

23 November 2026
Letter published.